AI Consultants vs. Big Four Consulting, by the Numbers.
A quantified, source-linked comparison for VPs of Engineering, CIOs, and Chief Innovation Officers being quoted $250k – $500kby Salesforce, IBM, Deloitte, or Accenture for AI chatbot implementations that ship in 9 months and don't work.
Five numbers that explain the entire delta.
- 16×Median cost deltaBig Four$2.4MOperator$150k
- 3.7×Median time-to-productionBig Four11 moOperator12 wk
- 40×Headcount on the projectBig Four40 peopleOperator1 operator
- 0Switching cost on day 91Big Four18-mo lock-inOperatorYour code
- ∞Model portabilityBig FourLicensed modelOperatorYour API keys
The line-by-line breakdown.
Eight dimensions. Big Four default on the left. Independent operator on the right. A plain-English reason in the gutter for why the delta exists. No editorializing.
The Honest RFP Test.
Five questions to ask any AI vendor before you sign. If they can't answer all five in plain English — no hedging, no "it depends on discovery," no pointing at a platform deck — walk.
- 01
Who actually writes the code?
Trap: If the answer is 'a global delivery team' or 'our offshore practice,' you're buying a supervisor, not a builder.
Green: A named human (or tight named team) who you meet weekly. You have their calendar and their GitHub.
- 02
Where does the AI run, and whose account pays the inference bill?
Trap: If it runs in the vendor's cloud on the vendor's API keys, you are renting software on a 3-year lease disguised as a license.
Green: Your cloud. Your API keys. Your inference invoice from Anthropic / OpenAI / AWS Bedrock.
- 03
What happens on day 91 if I stop paying?
Trap: 'You'll lose access to the platform.' Translation: the vendor owns the thing you just paid to build.
Green: Nothing happens. The code is in your GitHub. The model is on your API key. It keeps running forever.
- 04
Show me a working system you shipped in the last 90 days.
Trap: Case study decks. Logo walls. 'Unfortunately that client is under NDA.' Every firm says this. Almost none have a live URL.
Green: A live URL I can open. A demo I can log into. A client I can call. Dated. Linked. Verifiable.
- 05
What's the fixed price, and exactly what triggers a change order?
Trap: 'It depends on discovery.' 'We'll scope in phase zero.' 'T&M with a not-to-exceed.' The real cost is 2 – 4× the quote.
Green: One number. One scope document. A written definition of what requires a new SOW. Signed before work starts.
Steal this framework. Run it against every vendor — including me. If I fail a question, I shouldn't get the work.
Four recent ships.
Every link opens a live, trafficked URL. No case-study PDFs. No logos from 2019. No "client under NDA." The full portfolio sits at jonyeazel.ai.
- 7 days
MUD\WTR Shopify PDP
Conversion-optimized product detail page for a 9-figure DTC brand.
- 3 weeks
Rose Howard Estate
Luxury real-estate microsite. Full brand + build.
- 2 weeks
Dialer.io
SaaS product surface, from landing to dashboard.
- 4 weeks
v0 University
AI education platform. Live, trafficked, in-production.
The hard ones, answered.
The 40-person team is not building — it is coordinating. Most of that headcount is project management, layered accountability, and meetings about meetings. The actual code is written by a small handful of offshore engineers. AI-native tooling (Claude, v0, Cursor) lets one senior operator output what used to take a full pod. The tradeoff is real: you lose the paper-trail comfort of 40 timesheets. You gain 16× cost savings and 3.7× faster delivery.
This is the most common enterprise objection, and the answer is structural: the code is in your GitHub from day one, the infra is in your cloud from day one, and every architectural decision is documented as a committed ADR (architecture decision record). You could hire any competent engineer to continue the work tomorrow. This is categorically not true of a Salesforce or IBM implementation, where the vendor lock-in is the product.
Correct, and the page is explicit about that. Big Four firms provide the paper trail, procurement comfort, and risk-transfer theater that some organizations genuinely require — particularly in federal, regulated healthcare (FedRAMP, HIPAA with certain carriers), and deeply political environments where 'nobody ever got fired for hiring Accenture' is the real buying criteria. If that's the decision framework, this comparison is not for you. If the decision framework is 'we want the working system,' the comparison stands.
The delta is not from cutting corners on the work — it is from cutting the overhead around the work. The Big Four model bills five layers of management for every hour of engineering. An independent operator bills one. The code quality, architecture, and model selection are equivalent or better (see: frontier models vs. 2023-era GPT-4o wrappers). What you are not paying for is the steering committee, the weekly status deck, and the partner who shows up once a month to 'provide executive air cover.'
Standard enterprise paperwork is pre-cleared and available on request: MSA, MNDA, SOW, SOC 2 (via partner), HIPAA BAA, W-9, and $2M professional liability / $1M cyber insurance certificates. Security architecture defaults to least-privilege IAM, scoped service accounts, KMS-managed secrets, and audit logs routed to your SIEM.
Real ones, worth naming: (1) capacity — one person cannot run two $150k engagements in parallel, so timing matters; (2) specialization gaps — deep FedRAMP, HIPAA, or mainframe-integration work needs partners; (3) political cover — if the project needs 'Accenture said so' to survive internal debate, an operator cannot provide that. Be honest about which of these apply to your situation before starting.
Every portfolio URL is live and linked. Every number is a median range drawn from public pricing pages of the named firms (Accenture, IBM Consulting, Deloitte, Salesforce Professional Services) and from independently-shipped work on this domain. If you find a claim that cannot be verified, email the site and it will be corrected publicly with a changelog entry.
Run The Honest RFP Test with me.
Send the quote you're holding. I'll walk you through all five questions in 30 minutes and tell you honestly whether to sign, renegotiate, or walk. Free. No pitch.
If you'd rather save this for later: · text version